Pages

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Stuff You Shouldn't Post on the Internet










Spock - Evil Spock
Image credit: Photo by
Dave Friedel on Flickr
Licensed under Creative Commons

I was going to write this post about Facebook.  And Privacy.  And Privacy's evil twin, Secrecy.  And how when we say Privacy, we often really mean Secrecy.  Because not only do well-intentioned but befuddled people confuse the two, but addicts and other evil-doers also (gasp!) use the sacred name of Privacy as a mask for the nasty, putrid character of Secrecy.

I was going to tell you to learn to recognize Secrecy. (It's the one with the goatee.  Oh, and also the one you've lied to someone about, explicitly or implicitly.)  And I was going to ask you to think carefully about whether you are really, really talking about nice, clean-shaven Privacy or if you are actually sporting evil facial hair and hiding from people for fear of being judged.  And that being worried about how it will look if people know that you are who you are is not Privacy, it's illness. And I was going to tell you to live well and without secrets.  And not be both so scared and so freaking judgmental.  And if you live with secrets anyway (you devious person!), then Deal With It if you are outed.  Because it's your fault for having them.

And as for Privacy online (or Secrecy online for that matter), I was going to inform you that it's an illusion.  Nothing on the Internet is really private; it's on millions of computers around the world, forever.  If it's truly private, don't put it out there or at least recognize the risks, because demanding Privacy online is the equivalent of yelling at people for walking into a public restroom while you're using it with all the doors wide open.  Good, honest, non-goatee wearing Privacy is what the confines of our own Real Life are about. (It's all the stuff I don't post on the Internet. Whatever that is.) *

And I was going to tell you all this as someone whose life and marriage has been marred by secrets, so that I can see the difference between Privacy and Secrecy in the big, ugly gash burned through the middle of my existence.  And as someone who has this secret blog with a secret identity.  And who litters the Internet with posts about whole bunches of stuff that, really, I'd rather people in my Real Life didn't know.  All of which makes me one of the World's Experts on Privacy, Secrecy and Stuff Not to Post on the Internet.

But as I was writing that post, being all opinionated and you'ing you about how to do stuff right, you whiny and incompetent Facebook users, I saw that all that stuff about you was (surprise!) really stuff about me.  And not just stuff about me, but putting all my worst fears and worst character defects right out there in your face.  I mean, really, that kind of bossy, judgmental, know-it-all-ism -- telling you about how you shouldn't be bossy or judgmental because it makes me have to deal with my uncomfortable feelings about Secrecy and Privacy and how they've gotten all mixed up in my life to the point where it makes me want to punch them both square in the nose -- that's me at my total worst.  And that is the very kind of secret I shouldn't post on the Internet.

10 comments:

  1. Privacy is a right, secrecy is a choice.

    It's all about respectful boundaries, isn't it?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't know if secrecy is always such a bad thing. For example, I'm not ashamed of my social security number, but I keep it secret anyway.

    Unfortunately, we don't live in a perfect world and we can't be open about everything.

    I also have been burned by others' secrets, and I've kept my own. Maybe the issue is trust or denial, and maybe it's shame. Keeping some information secret (social security number, bank account number) to protect yourself is obviously smart. But, keeping other types of information secret to protect your status, self-image, or benefits might be more dubious, although there are circumstances where it's absolutely necessary. The kinds of lies that bend another person's reality are a whole other issue.

    I remember as a kid being taught, "Lying is always wrong!" But also, "Don't talk about what goes on in our house," and "Don't question what you see." It's a confusing message, and trust and secrecy have been problematic for me.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Astrid, the line is definitely blurry, but I'd say you are keeping your social security number private (and very reasonably so), but not secret.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is brilliant!

    (Why am I not surprised?)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am glad that you wrote about this. I think that keeping secrets from those we love is one of the worst things to do. And really, the other person can tell that something is amiss. Keeping secrets in the name of privacy is twisted, especially when it comes to the internet. There is nothing private on here. Even what people Google isn't private. Thanks for a great post.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The boundary between privacy and secrecy seems to be as much defined by the intentions of those who would use the information as much as those of the information's owners. We only keep secrets from those who would use them against us - and it's so hard to tell whether they'd be doing that justifiably or not.

    Fab post.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow. Fantastic - I'm right there with you sister. Life is deliciously wrapped in gray areas that are so delicate to move through with ones personal boundaries and integrity intact. This debate is one of them.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I was befuddled by facebook's new "privacy" policy. What the heck is everybody so darned afraid of? Am I the only person in history who is not currently being cyber stalked? Really? Life is too short to be wasted on such senseless worry, I say.

    I say that, yet my blog is "secret." It has to be because of work. I also have a nonsecret (work-related) blog which everybody at work reads. The secrecy of my personal blog has always bothered me (I truly believe that we're only as sick as our secrets), but I've learned to accept it. I keep writing on my secret blog because there are things I wish to say even though I am only exposing part of myself, the self which exists away from work.

    Maybe someday I can live a totally open, honest life.

    Hugs,
    Betty

    ReplyDelete
  9. Spot on!
    I struggle so much with this, how to remain truthful and honest while protecting the privacy of those dear to me. It's hard to differentiate. I don't know how to tell things without really telling them.
    I don't know how to face reactions and stand my own ground. And sometimes, I need to voice something without actually speaking to the people it concerns most. Which is... well... not a nice thing to do, but the best I'm capable of doing at this given moment. So I end up not speaking at all, just shutting down and struggling in silence.

    ReplyDelete
  10. And I read this right after I posted a big whine about not being able to be fully open and honest about things in my life.

    I guess I needed this, too.

    ReplyDelete