![]() |
| Image credit: Photo by si1very on Flickr Licensed under Creative Commons |
My friend Ellie tells me she can tell by the way someone writes whether or not that person is conventionally attractive. She says people who grow up knowing that society likes the way they look have a different voice than people who don't. They don't need to describe themselves. I thought of that as I wondered if my setting describes itself, if the landscape around me infuses itself into my writing even though I try not to describe it directly.
Am I perched in a skyscraper listening to cars whiz past my window? Am I nestled in a cabin with the world hushed outside under a blanket of December snow? Am I peering out at the dark shadow of a cactus against the night sky or straining to see anything at all in an inky, rustling sea of withered prairie grass? Am I in a humid river valley or high in the mountains where that river is born? City, country or suburb? Wet, dry, cold, warm, temperate or extreme? North, south, east or west? And does it matter?
Does the story change if I walk Janie to school or a bus stop past graffiti tagged buildings or down a dirt road past a cow? Does it matter if Austen's school has 20 students or 200 or 2000? Is my husband different if he's a small town businessman or a big city executive? Would I be thinking differently if I were writing this snuggled under a fleece blanket in front of a fire or listening to a sea breeze fan palm trees?
Do our outsides affect our insides so that there's no escaping them? Do we become where we are? (And is anyone else thinking of Marta's musings on writing now?)

Interesting ideas. I often wondered if I would be the same person had I grown up in a different country. Seriusly If I were born into a country that mandated I cover from head to toe or have my genetalia mutilated - I probobly would have been killed by my male family members because I was too outspoken and hard to control as a child.
ReplyDeleteI do think our outsides affect our insides - I know I grew up feeling ugly and every so often I slip back into that ugly mind frame. Life is so dark in that mindset.
I really do think that the power of our mind is so great - sometimes it is as simple as changing your mind - to make change happen in our lives.
Wow, what your friend Ellie said is really interesting and I'd have to agree, except that I'd add the condition "except if you're anonymously writing about sex addiction." There's just something about that subject--because it's so misunderstood--that spurs a person to write "and I really am attractive--I swear!"
ReplyDeleteHa! Margaux! It's true; we sex addict codies do tend to have to trumpet our hotness. ;)
ReplyDeleteI have really been wondering so much if my voice has changed for my readers since I put my face out there. What do you think?
ReplyDeleteDoes the story change if I walk Janie to school or a bus stop past graffiti tagged buildings or down a dirt road past a cow? Does it matter if Austen’s school has 20 students or 200 or 2000? Is my husband different if he’s a small town businessman or a big city executive? Would I be thinking differently if I were writing this snuggled under a fleece blanket in front of a fire or listening to a sea breeze fan palm trees?
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely, categorically YES!
Our surroundings, the time we grow up in, and more than anything, the socioeconomic level we grow up shape who we are, and where we are going in life. Even those who break free from the direction most of their peers take, carry their background with them.
I admit to not connecting the way a person writes with how they look (now I have something else to angst about!), but I do believe I can tell how a person feels about their looks by the way they carry themselves and look at the world. Can't you usually spot those people who know they are attractive? Or at least think they are? Maybe I should say there are certain mannerisms of people who knowing use their looks to get through life. They seem to give off an aura of having no clue what it is like to be less attractive, like they can't fathom people not thinking of them as good-looking.
ReplyDeleteMaybe I'm wrong. Maybe they're just as insecure as the rest of us.
That's such an interesting question, MPJ. I think it has to affect your writing. I'm sure my voice is different coming from suburbia now than it would be if I still lived in a huge city with a sprawling urban landscape. And that is also an interesting point about attractiveness and voice. I think it probably holds some validity.
ReplyDelete